When it comes time to replace your roof, the decision usually narrows down to two contenders: the traditional Asphalt Shingle and the increasingly popular Metal Roof.
Asphalt shingles have been the standard in American housing for decades due to their affordability. However, metal roofing has seen a massive surge in residential use, promising superior durability and energy savings.
But is metal worth the extra cost? Or is asphalt still the best value for your money? Let’s dive deep into the comparison.
1. Cost Comparison: Upfront Investment
This is the biggest factor for most homeowners. There is a significant price gap between the two materials.
-
Asphalt Shingles: This is the budget-friendly option. It is easier to manufacture and faster to install, keeping labor costs low.
-
Metal Roofing: Metal requires specialized labor and more expensive materials (steel, aluminum, or copper), making the upfront cost much higher.
| Material Type | Average Cost Per Square Foot (Installed) | Cost for 2,000 Sq. Ft. Roof |
| Asphalt Shingles (Architectural) | $4.50 – $7.00 | $9,000 – $14,000 |
| Metal (Standing Seam) | $9.00 – $16.00 | $18,000 – $32,000 |
Verdict: If your primary concern is immediate budget, Asphalt wins hands down. Metal can cost 2 to 3 times more upfront.
2. Lifespan and Durability: The Long Game
While asphalt is cheaper today, metal pays off over time. A roof is a long-term investment, and this is where metal shines.
-
Asphalt Shingles: Typically last 15 to 25 years. They are prone to thermal cracking, curling, and losing granules over time. Severe hail can easily damage them.
-
Metal Roofing: Designed to last 40 to 70 years. Metal is impervious to rot, insects, and mildew. It can withstand wind gusts up to 140 mph and is highly resistant to fire (Class A rating).
The Replacement Factor: In the time you own a metal roof, you might have to replace an asphalt roof 2 or 3 times.
Verdict: Metal is the clear winner for longevity.
3. Energy Efficiency and Eco-Friendliness
In 2025, energy costs are a major concern. Your roof plays a huge role in your home’s heating and cooling bills.
-
Asphalt Shingles: Asphalt absorbs radiant heat from the sun. In the summer, this heat transfers into your attic and home, forcing your air conditioner to work harder. Although “cool shingles” exist, standard shingles are heat magnets.
-
Metal Roofing: Metal reflects solar radiant heat, which can reduce cooling costs by 10% to 25%. Additionally, metal roofs are often made from recycled materials and are 100% recyclable at the end of their life, whereas old asphalt shingles end up in landfills.
Verdict: Metal is the superior choice for energy savings and environmental impact.
4. Resale Value (ROI)
Will you get your money back when you sell the house?
According to Remodeling Magazine’s Cost vs. Value Report, metal roofs generally offer a higher return on investment (ROI) at resale compared to asphalt.
-
Asphalt ROI: Homebuyers expect a functional roof, but a standard shingle roof rarely adds significant “premium” value.
-
Metal ROI: A metal roof is a selling point. Buyers know they won’t have to replace it for decades, and they appreciate the energy savings. You can typically recoup 60% to 85% of the cost of a metal roof upon resale.
5. Aesthetics and Curb Appeal
This is subjective, but important.
-
Asphalt Shingles: They offer a classic, traditional look that blends in well with most suburban neighborhoods. If you have an HOA (Homeowners Association), they might actually require asphalt shingles to maintain uniformity.
-
Metal Roofing: Standing seam metal offers a sleek, modern, industrial look. It looks fantastic on modern farmhouses or contemporary homes but might look out of place on a traditional colonial house (unless you use metal shingles designed to look like slate/wood).
Summary: Which One Should You Choose?
To simplify your decision, use this checklist based on your current situation:
Choose Asphalt Shingles If:
-
You have a limited upfront budget.
-
You plan to move out of the house in less than 10 years.
-
Your HOA prohibits metal roofing.
-
You prefer a traditional look that matches your neighbors.
Choose Metal Roofing If:
-
This is your “forever home” and you never want to re-roof again.
-
You live in an area with extreme weather (high winds, heavy snow, or wildfire risk).
-
You want to lower your monthly energy bills.
-
You prefer a modern aesthetic and eco-friendly materials.
Final Thoughts
Both materials are excellent choices in their own right. Asphalt offers cost-effective protection, while metal offers premium performance and longevity. The “best” roof is simply the one that fits your budget and future plans for the home.
